PNAS Nexus Real-World Comparison: Tirzepatide Drives 14.7% vs Semaglutide 10.8% Mean Weight Loss, Nearly Twice the High-Responder Rate, Fewer GI and Fatigue Events
A real-world comparison of tirzepatide and semaglutide for obesity by Venkatakrishnan and colleagues, published in PNAS Nexus on June 16, reported mean body-weight reductions of 14.7% on tirzepatide versus 10.8% on semaglutide at one year. The tirzepatide arm produced close to twice the proportion of 'high responders' (more than 15% body-weight loss) and lower rates of GI events, headache, and fatigue. Female and white patients responded more strongly on either drug than male, black, or Hispanic patients, who were more frequently in the under-5% weight-loss tier. The findings track with SURMOUNT-5's head-to-head trial result and the April 13 OMA Truveta poster but add a new demographic-disparity dimension that should inform real-world treatment selection.